The Robbie Williams story is among the tabloids’ barbs, however our darkish obsession with movie star persists | El Hunt

netflix’s new documentary makes good on its promise to current Robbie Williams as you’ve got by no means seen him earlier than, and never simply in displaying the era-defining good-looking younger man, now 50, principally in mattress, squirming in his pants. The movie’s director, Joe Perlman, collects hours of behind-the-scenes archival footage, a lot of which Williams has by no means seen earlier than, and exhibits it to him on his laptop computer to get his response.

One of the harrowing clips is a video Williams recorded in 2007. It exhibits him apparently alone, hooked on medicine, and studying on-line feedback out loud. “Robbie Williams is music for individuals who do not feel,” he says, his face grey and his eyes sunken. “Rob is an leisure business investor” – sure, I’m… “Robbie Williams is a fucking joke.”

The story — a few star being constructed up, torn down, and left to create life from the wreckage — is now acquainted. Perlman made it his major topic, having made related retrospective movies with the Eighties boy band, the now-grown Harry Potter crew, and Scottish songwriter Lewis Capaldi.

Right here, what emerges as soon as once more is a bleak image of tabloid journalism, and the price of dwelling below its scrutiny. Williams maybe differed from Perelman’s earlier topics in his advanced public persona: he attracted consideration as a lot as he rebelled towards it.

By up to date requirements of who deserves sympathy, Williams is low-ranking, seen as possessing a protecting defend of privilege: straight, white, male, able-bodied. Nevertheless, he appeared to crumble below the pressures positioned on him, at the same time as a pure artist.

Williams was generally trailed by 300 photographers at a time, in double-decker buses and helicopters. The doc exhibits him on the telephone to the Solar newspaper, difficult its “Strobe Williams” headline. He later criticized the newspaper’s leisure columnist Victoria Newton from the jacuzzi.

“I felt like I used to be studying day by day in print what a hateful individual I used to be,” Williams says now. Each try to contain the press or play it at its personal sport will backfire. Williams brings up “Angels,” a tune that nearly everybody loves and is derided as middle-of-the-road and a crowd-pleaser; He tried one thing new he believed in (on the time, a minimum of) with Rudebox, and was ridiculed.

It’s clear that the long-standing “hate” has eroded Williams’ self-confidence. Typically, in footage from the Rudebox period, he appears like a hunted animal. “It doesn’t matter what I do, it doesn’t matter what I write, regardless of how I sing, it doesn’t matter what I say – in my dwelling nation, the press will hate me a lot,” he says.

Just lately, there have been loads of appears on the cruelty of movie star tradition within the 2000s — from Britney Spears describing the “fixed drumbeat of stress from the paparazzi” that precipitated her downfall, and Posh and Becks talking out, of their Netflix documentary, about The stalking that accompanied their relationship.

Once I learn the press from the time, I used to be shocked by the unverified vitriol that was discovered printed beneath a byline and a hilarious header picture. However as a lot as we like to inform ourselves that we now reside in kinder instances, I am not satisfied. And in comparison with twenty years in the past, we have actually set some floor guidelines: Commenting on a star’s weight, for instance (which Williams struggled with for a very long time), is now framed as false curiosity or an oblique praise.

However regardless that we managed to get essentially the most horrific hits below the belt, that does not make up for the scale of the fashionable enviornment and the brutal tempo of the sport. With social media, it isn’t simply journalists who’ve the appropriate to specific their opinions, it is everybody – and though the press could also be much less inclined to overtly marketing campaign towards pop stars, X (previously Twitter) exhibits no such reticence.

It is exhausting to not get the impression that our media and leisure industries are eroding our empathy. Watching Williams, harm by important or dismissive opinions of his music, made me take into consideration the informal photographs I’ve taken of individuals within the public eye. It’s uncomfortable to comprehend, even within the comparatively brief interval of my profession, how many individuals are now not with us.

It is easy, while you remark publicly about celebrities – whether or not in a newspaper or on social media – to inform your self you are being important: they’re wealthy, they’re well-known, they select to be judged on their artwork and reside their lives in public. However did they actually do this? Does the reward justify the hurt?

I do not wish to reside in a world the place, if we won’t say something good, we do not say something in any respect, even whether it is attainable to take action. On the very least, these documentaries function a cautionary story, warning that the leisure business shouldn’t be for weak or thin-skinned individuals. However there’s a steadiness to be struck – how a lot ought to we anticipate people to endure for our leisure. These are pop stars, not politicians: there are a lot of simply targets for our collective disdain, targets the place stress can transfer us to a greater, extra simply world.

However whether or not we cheer for extra or demand their departure, our widespread obsession with celebrities has little energy for good – and nice potential for hurt.

It is all too straightforward to think about a tragic ending to Williams’ story, however the collection ends on an encouraging notice, with Williams Healing and happy (Though he’s nonetheless too traumatized to return to the UK), he’s a faithful husband and father of 4 kids. Nevertheless it’s too straightforward, generally, to think about a tragic ending. Little question he’ll obtain shifting reward. Presently, it has a two-star score for being “hardcore.” But when he’s self-absorbed, this solely displays our obsession.

Elle Hunt is a contract journalist

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *